Smartwatches Significantly Overestimate How Many Calories Are Burned

TUESDAY, Sept. 8, 2026 (HealthDay News) -- Smartwatches significantly overestimate how many calories people burn during exercise, according to a study published online July 29 in PLOS One.Jason Kostrna, from Florida International University in Miami, and colleagues evaluated the accuracy of smartwatch-derived physical activity energy expenditure estimates compared to indirect calorimetry, and examined whether error varied by device brand, body fat percentage, and skin tone. The analysis included participant-device pairings: 52 participants wearing Apple Watch Series 8; 51 wearing Garmin Forerunner 955; 50 wearing Samsung Galaxy Watch 5; and 44 wearing Fitbit Sense 2.The researchers found significant mean bias for three of four devices, with the nonsignificant Fitbit bias depending on device-specific outlier removal. Errors in smartwatch calorie estimates ranged roughly from 15 to 25 percent, with averages for the worst-performing watches climbing higher (Apple mean: 21.60 kcal [95 percent confidence interval (CI), 11.59 to 31.60]; Garmin: 68.61 kcal [95 percent CI, 53.28 to 83.94]; Samsung: 56.76 kcal [95 percent CI, 45.11 to 68.41]; Fitbit: 3.14 kcal [95 percent CI, −8.96 to 15.24]). There were main effects for device, body fat percentage main, and a device-by-body fat percentage interaction, according to mixed-effects models. Across all brands, physical activity energy expenditure error increased with adiposity."You can't treat the calories burned number it gives you as an accurate number," Kostrna said in a statement. "You could be hundreds of calories off each week and easily end up in a calorie surplus when you think you're in a calorie deficit."Abstract/Full Text.Sign up for our weekly HealthDay newsletter

Smartwatches Significantly Overestimate How Many Calories Are Burned

Related Stories

Your Smartwatch May Be Overestimating Your Calorie Burn

Healthier Fat Choices Linked to Longer Life After Prostate Cancer Diagnosis

Healthier Fat Choices Linked To Longer Life After Prostate Cancer Diagnosis

Together, Two Everyday Health Factors Double Death Risk In Midlife And Beyond